Challenging Coaching Book Summary By John Blakey and Ian Day

*This post contains affiliate links, and we may earn an affiliate commission without it ever affecting the price you pay.

Challenging Coaching provides readers with a comprehensive look at the traditional coaching model and introduces a better alternative for business coaching in the 21st century.

Authored by Blakey and Day, this book focuses on the FACTS approach which encourages delivery of "challenging feedback," accountability, setting courageous goals, high levels of tension, and systems thinking so that clients can reach their highest potential.

In addition to introducing the FACTS approach, the authors provide both extensive research and real-world observations that demonstrate how companies can unlock greater success through challenging coaching.

Through helpful discussions surrounding this new methodology, Challenging Coaching is an invaluable resource for those looking to boost performance in themselves or their teams.

Challenging Coaching Book

Book Name: Challenging Coaching (Going Beyond Traditional Coaching to Face the FACTS)

Author(s): John Blakey and Ian Day

Rating: 4.4/5

Reading Time: 22 Minutes

Categories: Management & Leadership

Author Bio

John Blakey and Ian Day are two experienced coaches who have extensive backgrounds in working with board-level leaders worldwide.

Their amazing work resulted in the writing of "Challenging Coaching: Learning to Understand and Influence for Sustainable Change”, which is a great book that provides key insights into effective coaching of influential people.

Blakey and Day offer their unique and invaluable account on how to influence leadership teams through challenging coaching which helps organizations understand sustainable change.

With their insight, readers will be able to gain knowledge on how to lead decision-makers effectively and with clarity.

A Fresh Take On Coaching: The Facts Approach To Finding Real Success

Real Success

Coaching has been in practice since the 1980s, when businesses first began to recognize the importance of retaining their top talent.

But with such an ever-changing working world, coaches need to ensure that they are up to date with the latest trends and technologies, so that they can truly help their clients reach their full potential.

Challenging Coaching takes a closer look at the roots of traditional coaching, which were inspired by support-oriented professions like counselling and psychotherapy.

While these principles are great for helping people in need of care, they may not be as effective in a faster-paced corporate world where decisions must be made quickly.

Traditional coaching often lacks accountability, and instead fuels leaders’ egos with fruits than challenging them with honest feedback.

That’s why Challenging Coaching argues for a change: a move away from myth-based coaching towards FACTS – Focus on Accountability & Top Solutions -which makes sure both values and outcomes matter when it comes to coaching clients.

This approach is based on evidence and best practices in real work environments: something coaches should strive for as we move further into the twenty-first century.

The Coaching Profession Is Rooted In Carl Rogers’ Person-Centered Approach

Traditional coaching models took their biggest influence from person-centered therapy, which was developed by Carl Rogers, one of the most influential therapists of the twentieth century.

His non-directive approach is based on a client having all the resources necessary for growth.

Thus, the coach’s role is to create an environment where they can develop and grow without judgements.

The popular Co-Active Coaching model and GROW model originate from Rogers’ principles too – with a focus on encouraging resourcefulness, creating a safe space for exploration, and understanding development through non-directive questioning.

For this reason, traditional coaching has had mainly support-oriented influences since its emergence in the 1980s.

It is these origins that give it its unique ability to back clients unconditionally while helping them find their own answers.

It’S Time For Coaching To Move Beyond Its Outdated Founding Principles

The foundation of coaching relies heavily on the support-orientated principles from the predecessors of psychotherapy and counselling.

This led to the emergence of three core coaching principles, which are widely accepted by the coaching literature:

The nondirective approach.

This principle states that it is not up to the coach to give advice or solve problems for their clients; rather, it is their role to ask questions, offer support, reflect and empower the client so that they can uncover their own answers.

Respecting the client’s agenda.

It’s always up to the client to decide which topics and areas they would like to work on during coaching sessions – not the coach.

Building rapport.

Effective progress can only be achieved when a strong bond between coach and client is built through empathy, trust, and creating a safe space where both parties can feel secure in providing constructive feedback.

These foundational principles have become foundational aspects which define modern-day coaching – however many are beginning to question whether its time for a shift in thinking and perspective amongst coaches today.

Traditional Coaching Principles Need To Be Challenged For Lasting Success

Lasting Success

Traditional coaching has some core principles that, while they emphasize client safety, can actually impede progress and carry a great risk of negative consequences.

The nondirective approach can lead to clients getting stuck in their current situation because the coach fails to make suggestions that could stimulate new solutions.

By sticking too rigidly to a client’s agenda, difficult issues may be overlooked and insufficient progress will be made.

Additionally, coaches need to be allowed to take clients out of their comfort zones and challenge them in order to help them reach their full potential.

When this is ignored, we see the consequences of “collusion, irrelevance and self-obsession” – outcomes nobody wants for a successful coaching experience.

The Benefits Of Facts-Based Coaching: Challenge And Support For Optimal Growth

It is fair to say that FACTS-based coaching is fundamentally more effective than traditional coaching.

With traditional coaching, the focus tends to be too much on support and not enough on challenge, leading to limited progress for the client.

FACTS-based coaching however finds the optimal balance of challenge and support, meaning the client can reach higher goals without being overwhelmed.

One way FACTS-based coaches are able to challenge their clients in a safe way is by entering the Zone of Uncomfortable Debate (ZOUD).

By pushing past the ‘zone of comfortable debate,’ coaches can address issues directly with their clients without compromising their relationship.

The key to sustaining this approach effectively lies in striking a balance between being challenging yet respectful and empathetic yet growth orientated.

To conclude, it’s clear that when your goal is meaningful change or growth, FACTS-based coaching is superior to traditional approaches thanks to its careful balancing and intelligently administered challenges.

Why Every Coach Should Provide Honest Feedback: Harness The Power Of Blind Spots, No-Go Areas And Bad News

Many traditional coaches struggle to provide honest feedback, due to a number of reasons: it could have been experienced as judgmental in the past, they may lack confidence in their feedback skills, or they may not feel they have the client’s permission to give feedback.

However, adjusting our mentality and pushing past these fears is key when it comes to giving necessary feedback – not doing so is a risk, as feedback can uncover blind spots, no-go areas, and help prevent bad decisions.

So how can a coach learn how to overcome their fear of delivering challenging and honest feedback? Firstly, by making sure that their advice is non-judgemental and critiques behavior instead of personality.

Secondly, by learning well-established models for providing feedback such as the four stage approach: Observe facts; Judge impact; Invite conversation; Agreement on action.

And finally by respectfully asking for permission from clients that are not open to receiving it.

Holding Business Leaders Responsible: The Role Of Coaches In Achieving Transparency And Accountability

Business Leaders

Clients must be held accountable to the commitments they make.

It’s no longer enough for them to simply hold themselves accountable and hope that their decisions are the right ones.

This was painfully evident during the BP oil spill crisis when CEO Tony Hayward struggled to recall any of the events he was asked about, further distancing himself from any responsibility.

The public responded with anger and rightly so; people demanded accountability from business leaders.

This is where coaches come in: they must move beyond traditional models of client responsibility and accountability, pushing clients to put their commitments down on paper in contract form so there’s an obvious marker for review if anything should go wrong.

Beyond this, coaches are tasked with ensuring that clients adhere to not just personal but also corporate commitments like mission statements, values, and social responsibility agendas.

With proper challenging coaching, it goes a long way toward holding business leaders accountable for their actions.

The Power Of Bold Goals: Why Taking Risks Is Necessary To Transform Businesses

In today’s global and rapidly changing economy, businesses need to have the flexibility to embrace transformation if they want to stay afloat.

Courageous goals are essential for tapping into creativity and allowing organizations to tackle the unknown.

Contrary to traditional goal-setting processes, this type of goal-setting frees companies from aiming only for “realistic” goals that typically yield reliable but smaller outcomes within a predetermined range.

Just look at how successful companies like Apple, Facebook, and Amazon have been thanks to setting courageous goals.

These companies weren’t just foolhardy; they boldly set forth with their vision of making an impact on the world.

When President John F Kennedy set out with his target of sending a man to the moon before the end of the decade, it was seen as a far-fetched dream until it actually happened.

It’s no wonder that businesses are now turning towards adopting this same approach in order to make an impact in our ever-evolving environment.

The Need For Tension: How Facts Coaching Can Help Push High-Achievers To Reach Excellence


When it comes to peak performance, tension is key.

Alexander Karelin found this out the hard way when he lost at the 2000 Olympic Games in a match against an opponent who he was considered heavily favored against.

Some thought that he was too nervous, but this seems unlikely since the concept of his opponent looming wasn’t much more threatening than those of his 887 previous victories or even three other Olympic finals.

Research on optimal performance has shown that athletes reach their highest levels by not being too comfortable nor too anxious.

This stands true even with enormously successful athletes and their coaches, who aim to find the perfect amount of tension so they can remain at the top of their game.

In regards to coaching and developing high-achieving people, traditional philosophies have stemmed from supportive counseling disciplines which focus largely on alleviating stress and tension; however, recent findings demonstrate that having a certain level of adrenalin is essential for utmost achievement.

The FACTS approach centers around keeping an optimal level of tension while pushing clients to push themselves even further beyond their limits they previously thought they should’ve stopped at.

The Moral Of Nick Leeson’S Story: The Importance Of System Awareness And Facts-Based Coaching

System awareness is a key element in preventing individuals from bringing down entire companies – something Nick Leeson of Barings Bank found out the hard way.

Without realizing that his decisions and investments would affect the whole system at Barings, he narrowly focused on his individual goals and ended up losing £827 million for the bank, with it eventually declaring bankruptcy.

The solution to this? Systemic thinking.

A coach trained in FACTS (Focused Analysis & Coaching Techiques) will help raise their client’s awareness of their actions and its implication on the wider system without taking a moral high ground or offering an opinion.

They will encourage clients to think intelligently so they can grow without inhibiting potential – something that could have saved Leeson and Barings had they adopted it beforehand.

In summary, understanding how individual decisions have a knock-on effect on entire organizations can be hard but with intelligent systemic thinking, as provided by FACTS coaching, companies can rest assured that such disasters won’t happen again.

Wrap Up

The Challenging Coaching Book provides an important message about the need for a more effective coaching model.

Traditional coaching techniques often fall short of providing optimal results, so the authors suggest their own F.A.C.T.S.—Honest Feedback, Accountable clients, Courageous goals, Tension for growth, and Systematic awareness—as a way to improve outcomes for both coaches and their clients alike.

Ultimately, this book highlights just how powerful coaching can be when applied in the right way — one that takes into account not only the individual’s needs but also has an eye on the bigger picture.

By following F.A.C.T.S., coaches will have the tools they need to maximize success with their clients and elevate their practice to reach its highest potential!

Arturo Miller

Hi, I am Arturo Miller, the Chief Editor of this blog. I'm a passionate reader, learner and blogger. Motivated by the desire to help others reach their fullest potential, I draw from my own experiences and insights to curate blogs.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.